“We must believe in free will. We have no choice” - Isaac B. Singer
I have, for a very long time, been fascinated by the way that we make choices, by the different factors that people consider, by the various ways that we weigh those factors, by what each of us chooses to prioritize, and by where we understand our decisions to be coming from.
Choices come in many shapes and sizes. There are the small choices that we have to make every day: what am I going to eat? Which route am I going to take on my way to work? What movie or show am I going to watch while procrastinating some bit of housework or, in my case, writing that I should be doing? And then there are the big choices: what job or course of study am I going to pursue? Where am I going to live? Which out of the box opportunity am I going to follow? When I reflect on my relationship with choice, I think I have had a much easier time with the bigger, more consequential choices than I have with the smaller, daily ones.
For many years I had a reputation for being very indecisive. When out to dinner with friends I would painstakingly vasulate between menu options, never quite able to settle on the “right choice”. I could spend hours in the grocery story walking between isles, unsure of what to put in my cart. Inevitably I would arrive back at home with grocery bags full of ingredients for full meals but nothing that I really wanted to eat. Occasionally while walking down the street with some unscheduled time I would find myself pacing back and forwarth unable to decide if I wanted to spend that time writing in a cafe, reading in a bookstore, or making a phone call from a park bench. Often my entire free hour would go by as I paced back and forwarth stuck in decision paralysis.
Despite all of this, I never really identified as being indecisive. Yes, I experienced decision paralysis. Sure, I would get stuck in spirals of indecision. Certainly, I would lose all sorts of time in the uncertainty of what it was that I wanted. But all of this lived side by side with another truth: When I knew what I wanted, I knew what I wanted. In the moments that I could connect with a true knowing, there was zero room for doubt, there was no place for indecision, the concept of decision itself didn’t even seem to be at play.
This clear knowing does occasionally show up in moments of daily life but those moments are small enough that I don’t even register them as choices, they are simply moments where I know what I want. It is only when the stakes are raised, when there is a clear choice point or decision moment that the question of a true knowing comes into play.
The first time I remember having a big decision to make I was twelve years old. I was walking with my dad up the main commercial street in my town and we were talking about my upcoming Bar Mitzvah. I had already been studying my torah portion, I had already started working on the speech I was going to give, but there was one element of the Bar Mitzvah that I had been avoiding making a decision about: the party. What kind of celebration did I want to have?
Because I was young for my grade, I had already been to a number of Bar Mitzvah parties and, for the most part, they didn’t feel like me. I wasn’t the most social twelve year old and the idea of a big party with a DJ and a lot of fanfare did not feel in line with who I was or what I valued. I didn’t want to do what the other kids had done simply because that’s what was expected, but I also wanted to do something. I wanted to mark the moment, I just wasn’t excited about any of the options that seemed to be available to me. I had no clarity, there was no knowing, and that made it feel impossible for me to decide what I wanted. How could I choose something if there wasn’t something that I knew I wanted?
Five years later I faced another, perhaps even more consequential, choice: what was I going to do after graduating high school. Again, I was not thrilled with the options in front of me. Most of my peers were going directly to college and, while part of me was excited about the possibilities that came with that choice, I wasn’t entirely sold on the idea of jumping right into more school. I remember sitting with my mom in the basement of my childhood home talking through all of the options in front of me and not being clearly excited about any of them, not having a clear knowing around what I should do.
In each of those cases, after much deliberation, I settled on a choice: my Bar Mitzvah concluded with a post service brunch for family and a few choice friends but no real party, and I went directly from highschool to college. In each of these cases I stand by the choice I came to but in neither of these cases did those choices have the most profound or lasting impact on my life.
When I think about the most pivotal moments in my life, the times where I took actions that had the greatest impact, the longest lasting or most transformational effect on who I was, how I lived, or what I would spend my time doing, choice didn’t feel like a factor at all. Or perhaps more accurately would be to say that in those cases the choice was only ever between whether I would follow my true knowing or whether I would not.
My first true knowing came to me in the middle of my Junior year in college. I knew, from somewhere deep in my core, that I was done with being in school. With the help of my father I figured out how to graduate a semester early. After graduating and taking what would have been that final semester to work, travel, and recenter myself, I knew that I wanted to go to graduate school to become a teacher. By my fourth year teaching I knew that it was time for me to leave teaching to start a summer camp.
In none of these moments did I feel like I was operating from a place of choice or decision. I was clear about what was important to me, I was clear about what I wanted, I was clear about what I was here to do, about the direction my life was pointing me towards. In each of these moments I had a clear knowing. And the more experience I have had with there being things that I deeply know, the less interest I have in operating from the place of decision.
When I feel most myself I am operating from a place of choice, I am operating from a place of knowing. It is only when I do not have a clear knowing that I am subject to the torturous state of being in choice.